Substitution of Sugar-Sweetened Beverages with Other Beverage Alternatives: A Review of Long-Term Health Outcomes

Published:March 04, 2015DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jand.2015.01.006

      Abstract

      Background

      Excessive consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) has become an intractable public health concern worldwide, making investigation of healthy beverage alternatives for SSBs imperative.

      Aim

      To summarize the available evidence on the effects of replacing SSBs with beverage alternatives on long-term health outcomes.

      Method

      We systematically retrieved studies from six electronic databases from inception to November 2013. Prospective cohort studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs) examining the effects of substituting beverage alternatives for SSBs on long-term health outcomes in both children and adults were included. The quality of included studies was assessed using the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network 50 methodology checklists.

      Results

      Six cohort studies and four RCTs were included in the systematic review with the quality rating ranging from acceptable to high. Evidence from both cohort studies and RCTs showed substitution of SSBs by various beverage alternatives was associated with long-term lower energy intake and lower weight gain. However, evidence was insufficient to draw conclusions regarding the effect of beverage substitution on other health outcomes, and which beverage alternative is the best choice.

      Conclusions

      Although studies on this topic are sparse, the available evidence suggests a potential beneficial effect on body weight outcomes when SSBs are replaced by water or low-calorie beverages. Further studies in this area are warranted to fully understand the long-term health implications of beverage substitutions.

      Keywords

      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Malik V.S.
        • Pan A.
        • Willett W.C.
        • Hu F.B.
        Sugar-sweetened beverages and weight gain in children and adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2013; 98: 1084-1102
        • Woodward-lopez G.
        • Kao J.
        • Ritchie L.
        To what extent have sweetened beverages contributed to the obesity epidemic?.
        Public Health Nutr. 2010; 14: 499-509
        • Vartanian L.R.
        • Schwartz M.B.
        • Brownell K.D.
        Effects of soft drink consumption on nutrition and health: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        Am J Public Health. 2007; 97: 667-675
        • Malik V.
        • Hu F.
        Sugar-sweetened beverages and health: Where does the evidence stand?.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2011; 94: 1161-1162
        • Hu F.B.
        Resolved: There is sufficient scientific evidence that decreasing sugar-sweetened beverage consumption will reduce the prevalence of obesity and obesity-related diseases.
        Obes Rev. 2013; 14: 606-619
        • Malik V.
        • Schulze M.
        • Hu F.
        Intake of sugar-sweetened beverages and weight gain: A systematic review.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2006; 84: 274-288
        • Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee
        Report of the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee on the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2010, to the Secretary of Agriculture and the Secretary of Health and Human Services.
        US Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Washington, DC2010
        • World Health Organization Europe
        Food Based Dietary Guidelines in the WHO European Region.
        WHO Regional Office for Europe Nutrition and Food Security Programme, Copenhagen, Denmark2003
        • Davis M.
        • Gance-Cleveland B.
        • Hassink S.
        • Johnson R.
        • Paradis G.
        • Resnicow K.
        Recommendations for prevention of childhood obesity.
        Pediatrics. 2007; 120: S229-S253
        • Pomeranz J.L.
        Advanced policy options to regulate sugar-sweetened beverages to support public health.
        J Public Health Policy. 2012; 33: 75-88
        • Chaloupka F.J.
        • Powell L.M.
        • Chriqui J.F.
        Sugar-sweetened beverages and obesity prevention: Policy recommendations.
        J policy Anal Manage. 2011; 30: 662-664
      1. Ballotpedia: An interactive almanac of US politics. City of Berkeley Sugary Beverages and Soda Tax Question, Measure D (November 2014). 2014. http://ballotpedia.org/City_of_Berkeley_Sugary_Beverages_and_Soda_Tax_Question,_Measure_D_(November_2014). Accessed December 21, 2014.

        • Kaiser K.A.
        • Shikany J.M.
        • Keating K.D.
        • Allison D.B.
        Will reducing sugar-sweetened beverage consumption reduce obesity? Evidence supporting conjecture is strong, but evidence when testing effect is weak.
        Obes Rev. 2013; 14: 620-633
        • Powell L.M.
        • Chriqui J.F.
        • Khan T.
        • Wada R.
        • Chaloupka F.J.
        Assessing the potential effectiveness of food and beverage taxes and subsidies for improving public health: A systematic review of prices, demand and body weight outcomes.
        Obes Rev. 2013; 14: 110-128
        • Maniadakis N.
        • Kapaki V.
        • Damianidi L.
        • Kourlaba G.
        A systematic review of the effectiveness of taxes on nonalcoholic beverages and high-in-fat foods as a means to prevent obesity trends.
        Clinicoeco Outcomes Res. 2013; 5: 519-543
        • Daniels M.C.
        • Popkin B.M.
        Impact of water intake on energy intake and weight status: A systematic review.
        Nutr Rev. 2010; 68: 505-521
        • Muckelbauer R.
        • Sarganas G.
        • Gruneis A.
        • Muller-Nordhorn J.
        Association between water consumption and body weight outcomes: A systematic review.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2013; 98: 282-299
        • Slavin J.
        Beverages and body weight: challenges in the evidence-based review process of the Carbohydrate Subcommittee from the 2010 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee.
        Nutr Rev. 2012; 70: S111-S120
        • Pereira M.
        Diet beverages and the risk of obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease: A review of the evidence.
        Nutr Rev. 2013; 71: 433-440
        • Hursel R.
        • Westerterp-Plantenga M.S.
        Catechin- and caffeine-rich teas for control of body weight in humans.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2013; 98: 1682S-1693S
        • Huxley R.
        • Lee C.M.
        • Barzi F.
        • et al.
        Coffee, decaffeinated coffee, and tea consumption in relation to incident type 2 diabetes mellitus: A systematic review with meta-analysis.
        Arch Intern Med. 2009; 169: 2053-2063
        • Bohn S.K.
        • Ward N.C.
        • Hodgson J.M.
        • Croft K.D.
        Effects of tea and coffee on cardiovascular disease risk.
        Food Funct. 2012; 3: 575-591
      2. Australian National Health and Medical Research Council. Eat for health: Dietary guidelines. 2013. http://www.nhmrc.gov.au/guidelines/publications/n55. Accessed April 22, 2013.

        • O'Neil C.E.
        • Nicklas T.A.
        • Zanovec M.
        • Kleinman R.E.
        • Fulgoni V.L.
        Fruit juice consumption is associated with improved nutrient adequacy in children and adolescents: The National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) 2003-2006.
        Public Health Nutr. 2012; 15: 1871-1878
        • Huth P.J.
        • DiRienzo D.B.
        • Miller G.D.
        Major scientific advances with dairy foods in nutrition and health.
        J Dairy Sci. 2006; 89: 1207-1221
        • Rice B.H.
        • Quann E.E.
        • Miller G.D.
        Meeting and exceeding dairy recommendations: Effects of dairy consumption on nutrient intakes and risk of chronic disease.
        Nutr Rev. 2013; 71: 209-223
        • Lacroix M.
        • Bos C.
        • Leonil J.
        • et al.
        Compared with casein or total milk protein, digestion of milk soluble proteins is too rapid to sustain the anabolic postprandial amino acid requirement.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2006; 84: 1070-1079
        • Dougkas A.
        • Reynolds C.
        • Givens I.
        • Elwood P.
        • Minihane A.
        Associations between dairy consumption and body weight: A review of the evidence and underlying mechanisms.
        Nutr Res Re. 2011; 24: 72-95
        • Chen M.
        • Pan A.
        • Malik V.S.
        • Hu F.B.
        Effects of dairy intake on body weight and fat: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2012; 96: 735-747
        • Boeing H.
        Nutritional epidemiology: New perspectives for understanding the diet-disease relationship?.
        Eur J Clin Nutr. 2013; 67: 424-429
      3. Human subjects research. 45 Federal Register (2010) (codified at 45 CFR §46).

        • Moher D.
        • Liberati A.
        • Tetzlaff J.
        • Altman D.G.
        • Group P.
        Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement.
        Open Med. 2009; 3: e123-e130
        • Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network
        Methodology checklist 3: Cohort studies.
        in: SIGN 50: A Guideline Developers' Handbook. The Network, Edinburgh, Scotland2012
        • Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network
        Methodology checklist 4: Randomized controlled trials.
        in: SIGN 50: A Guideline Developers' Handbook. The Network, Edinburgh, Scotland2012
        • Bai A.
        • Shukla V.
        • Bak G.
        • Wells G.
        Quality Assessment Tool Project Report.
        Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health, Ottawa, ON, Canada2012
        • West S.
        • King V.
        • Carey T.
        • et al.
        Systems to rate the strength of scientific evidence.
        Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD2002 (AHRQ Publication No. 02-E016)
        • Stookey J.D.
        • Constant F.
        • Gardner C.D.
        • Popkin B.M.
        Replacing sweetened caloric beverages with drinking water is associated with lower energy intake.
        Obesity (Silver Spring). 2007; 15: 3013-3022
        • Stookey J.D.
        • Constant F.
        • Popkin B.M.
        • Gardner C.D.
        Drinking water is associated with weight loss in overweight dieting women independent of diet and activity.
        Obesity (Silver Spring). 2008; 16: 2481-2488
        • Bernstein A.M.
        • de Koning L.
        • Flint A.J.
        • Rexrode K.M.
        • Willett W.C.
        Soda consumption and the risk of stroke in men and women.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2012; 95: 1190-1199
        • de Koning L.
        • Malik V.S.
        • Rimm E.B.
        • Willett W.C.
        • Hu F.B.
        Sugar-sweetened and artificially sweetened beverage consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes in men.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2011; 93: 1321-1327
        • Pan A.
        • Malik V.S.
        • Hao T.
        • Willett W.C.
        • Mozaffarian D.
        • Hu F.B.
        Changes in water and beverage intake and long-term weight changes: Results from three prospective cohort studies.
        Int J Obes (Lond). 2013; 37: 1378-1385
        • Pan A.
        • Malik V.S.
        • Schulze M.B.
        • Manson J.E.
        • Willett W.C.
        • Hu F.B.
        Plain-water intake and risk of type 2 diabetes in young and middle-aged women.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2012; 95: 1454-1460
        • Hu F.
        • Stampfer M.
        • Rimm E.
        • et al.
        Dietary fat and coronary heart disease: A comparison of approaches for adjusting for total energy intake and modeling repeated dietary measurements.
        Am J Epidemiol. 1999; 149: 531-540
        • Willet W.
        Nutritional Epidemiology.
        3rd ed. Oxford University Press, New York, NY2013
        • Ebbeling C.B.
        • Feldman H.A.
        • Osganian S.K.
        • Chomitz V.R.
        • Ellenbogen S.J.
        • Ludwig D.S.
        Effects of decreasing sugar-sweetened beverage consumption on body weight in adolescents: A randomized, controlled pilot study.
        Pediatrics. 2006; 117: 673-680
        • Ebbeling C.B.
        • Feldman H.A.
        • Chomitz V.R.
        • et al.
        A randomized trial of sugar-sweetened beverages and adolescent body weight.
        N Engl J Med. 2012; 367: 1407-1416
        • Albala C.
        • Ebbeling C.B.
        • Cifuentes M.
        • Lera L.
        • Bustos N.
        • Ludwig D.S.
        Effects of replacing the habitual consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages with milk in Chilean children.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2008; 88: 605-611
        • Tate D.F.
        • Turner-McGrievy G.
        • Lyons E.
        • et al.
        Replacing caloric beverages with water or diet beverages for weight loss in adults: Main results of the Choose Healthy Options Consciously Everyday (CHOICE) randomized clinical trial.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2012; 95: 555-563
        • Nawrot P.
        • Jordan S.
        • Eastwood J.
        • Rotstein J.
        • Hugenholtz A.
        • Feeley M.
        Effects of caffeine on human health.
        Food Addit Contam. 2003; 20: 1-30
        • Libuda L.
        • Kersting M.
        Soft drinks and body weight development in childhood: Is there a relationship?.
        Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care. 2009; 12: 596-600
      4. National Health and Medical Research Council. New clinical practice guidelines for managing overweight and obesity. 2013. http://www.nhmrc.gov.au/media/releases/2013/new-clinical-practice-guidelines-managing-overweight-and-obesity. Accessed August 20, 2013.

        • Malik V.
        • Popkin B.
        • Bray G.
        • Despres J.
        • Hu F.
        Sugar-sweetened beverages, obesity, type 2 diabetes metillus, and cardiovascular disease.
        Circulation. 2010; 121: 1356-1364
        • Fung T.T.
        • Malik V.
        • Rexrode K.M.
        • Manson J.E.
        • Willett W.C.
        • Hu F.B.
        Sweetened beverage consumption and risk of coronary heart disease in women.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2009; 89: 1037-1042
        • Malik V.S.
        • Sun Q.
        • van Dam R.M.
        • et al.
        Adolescent dairy product consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes in middle-aged women.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2011; 94: 854-861
        • Acheson K.J.
        • Gremaud G.
        • Meirim I.
        • et al.
        Metabolic effects of caffeine in humans: Lipid oxidation or futile cycling?.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2004; 79: 40-46
        • Phung O.J.
        • Baker W.L.
        • Matthews L.J.
        • Lanosa M.
        • Thorne A.
        • Coleman C.I.
        Effect of green tea catechins with or without caffeine on anthropometric measures: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
        Am J Clin Nutr. 2010; 91: 73-81
      5. Euromonitor International. Soft drinks: Euromonitor from trade sources/national statistics. 2015. Euromonitor Passport Database website. http://www.euromonitor.com/. Accessed January 5, 2015.

      Biography

      M. Zheng is a PhD candidate, School of Molecular Bioscience, University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.

      Biography

      M. Allman-Farinelli is a professor of dietetics, School of Molecular Bioscience, University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.

      Biography

      A. Rangan is a senior lecturer, School of Molecular Bioscience, University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.

      Biography

      B. L. Heitmann is a professor of nutrition epidemiology, Research Unit for Dietary Studies, Institute of Preventive Medicine, Bispebjerg and Frederiksberg Hospitals, the Capital Region, Copenhagen, Denmark, the National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Copenhagen, and The Boden Institute of Obesity, Nutrition, Exercise, and Eating Disorders, Sydney Medical School, University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.